Lost Anchorage

Fly by Night Club, Marx Bros. Cafe, and the Alaska legends that closed

In a city where darkness lasts twenty hours in winter, the places that kept the lights on mattered more than most. These were the legendary dives, roadhouses, and gathering spots that gave Anchorage its frontier character—establishments that felt like they'd been there since statehood. The Last Frontier loses its landmarks quietly.

Fly by Night Club

1980–2020

Spenard

The Story

Mr. Whitekeys ran this quirky performance space for 40 years with absurdist Alaskan humor and zero regard for mainland sensibilities. The "Whale Fat Follies" comedy shows skewered politicians, tourists, and Alaskans themselves. Touring musicians played here. Weird theater happened here. Anchorage laughed at itself here.

Why It's Missed

Because Alaska needs permission to laugh at itself, and Fly by Night gave it freely. When it closed in 2020, Anchorage lost its theatrical heart and its willingness to be ridiculous. Mr. Whitekeys understood that satire is survival at 61°N.

"Fly by Night was where Anchorage went to remember it had a sense of humor." — Anchorage Daily News

Last Known Address

3300 Spenard Rd, Anchorage

X Facebook LinkedIn Email

The Marx Bros. Cafe

1979–2014

Downtown

The Story

The fine dining restaurant in a converted house that proved Alaska could do sophisticated food. Chef Jack Amon took local ingredients—halibut, salmon, reindeer—and turned them into something elegant enough to compete with Seattle. For 35 years, this was where Anchorage celebrated anniversaries and closed deals. Visitors came expecting salmon jerky and left reconsidering what Alaska cuisine meant.

Why It's Missed

Because it showed that Alaska wasn't just a frontier—it was a place that could compete on a national stage. The halibut was perfect. The wine pairings were thoughtful. When Jack Amon retired and closed Marx Bros. in 2014, Anchorage lost its proof that refinement could survive this far north.

"Marx Bros. put Anchorage on the culinary map." — Alaska Magazine

Last Known Address

627 W 3rd Ave, Anchorage

X Facebook LinkedIn Email

Cook Inlet Book Company

1982–2012

Downtown

The Story

The independent bookstore in the Fifth Avenue Mall with staff who actually read, local author signings that mattered, and an Alaska section that understood the state as literature, not just commodity. For 30 years, this was Anchorage's literary anchor. Then the owners retired and Amazon won.

Why It's Missed

Because downtown lost a reason to visit. Because the staff recommendations were better than any algorithm. Because Anchorage briefly had a bookstore that treated books as culture, and now it doesn't. When Cook Inlet closed in 2012, it felt like the city had decided literature was optional.

"Cook Inlet Book Company was Alaska's bookstore." — Anchorage Press

Last Known Address

415 W 5th Ave, Anchorage

X Facebook LinkedIn Email

The Sourdough Mining Company

1976–2018

Midtown

The Story

Gold rush theme. Sawdust floors. Mining equipment on the walls. Crab legs by the pound. Absurdly large sundaes. For 42 years, the Sourdough Mining Company was Anchorage at its most unapologetically touristy—and locals ate here anyway. For special occasions. For king crab. For the spectacle.

Why It's Missed

Because Alaska is allowed to embrace its stereotypes and still have fun. Because the king crab was genuinely excellent. Because sometimes a frontier theme restaurant with massive sundaes is exactly what you need. When it closed in 2018, Anchorage lost permission to be corny.